Darryl Robinson, A Challenge for Ecocide Scholarship: Engaging with Science, Survival, and the Scope of Criminal Law, The International Journal of Human Rights, Vol. 30(6), pp. 1341-1369 (May 2026)

This article poses two challenges for current ecocide scholarship. Numerous well-intentioned scholars insist that all severe harm should be criminalized outright, without reference to environmental principles. This article urges such proponents to address two overlooked crucial concerns. First, humans, like all creatures, must have some footprint to live. Maintaining 8 billion huan lives presents some grim ‘choice of evils’ predicaments. Some high-impact activities supporting millions of people may be the least harmful of the available bad options. If so, then a definition of ecocide must distinguish punishable and non-punishable conduct. Proponents of the absolute approach should address serious empirical and ethical questions. Second, proponents should address the limits of criminal law. Activities currently justified under sound principles need to be improved, but this will require extensive societal reforms. Are police and prisons appropriate tools to direct complex societal reforms? Or should criminal law assist by focusing on egregious violations of principles? Absent solutions to these concerns, a crime of ecocide should factor in both the severity of impact and the wrongfuness of the conduct. Such a crime is more effective than the alternative of an absolute standard with a bar so high that no human projects reach it.